Some records arrive too late to matter in their own time and too early to be properly understood. Sometimes Sounds Collapse, the lone six-song document from Washington, D.C.’s The Elusive, belongs to that rare category of work that serves as an artifact yet indicates the revolution on the post-hardcore scene at the time. Recorded in 1997, released quietly in 1998 on Shute Records, and long out of print, it now resurfaces in its first vinyl edition. Remixed by J. Robbins and remastered by Dan Coutant, it sounds as volatile, urgent, and necessary as the day it was tracked. The Elusive were never meant to last. Born from fragments of Corm, Jenhitt, and The Tilden Shirtwaist Fire, they existed for less than a year, played only a handful of shows, and dissolved before anyone outside of basements and small clubs even knew their name. Yet those who caught them, or who stumbled upon the original CD, recognized a force that sat squarely in the lineage of D.C. post-hardcore while pushing toward something rough, fractured, and expansive. In hindsight, it’s no surprise that members John Davis and Chris Richards went on to form Q And Not U, a band that would become one of the last truly transformative groups on Dischord Records. Sometimes Sounds Collapse is the blueprint of that transformation.
Listening now, it’s hard not to marvel at how complete the vision already was. These six songs carry the DNA of Fugazi, Jawbox, At The Drive-In, or maybe Drive Like Jehu, sharp guitars slashing against each other, rhythms that shift from constraint to explosion, vocals that blur between raw shouts and melodic incisions. The Elusive understood that post-hardcore was a willingness to interrogate form, to stretch tension until it frays, to fuse abrasion with clarity in raw, abrasive, unfiltered ways. The recording captures a band writing with so much understanding for structure, depth, and dynamics. The guitars are angular, sometimes dueling, sometimes colliding, always restless. There is melody buried in the fractures, emerging with such power from time to time. The basslines move with such a presence, like a more than necessary tool in their arsenal that improves their powerful output. The precise and unpredictable drumming constantly shifts, cleverly mapping the blueprint of every song. Even in its most melodic moments, this material bristles with agitation. The mastering does not smooth the edges. The sound is fuller, more three-dimensional, giving space to every shouted vocal layer, every serrated guitar line, every cymbal crash.
This is music made in the brief, flickering moment before ambition could calcify into careerism, before trends hardened into formulas. The Elusive existed only to play these songs, to capture them, and then to disappear. That purity shines through the record. You don’t hear compromise or any calculation, but a couple of musicians testing the limits of what post-hardcore could be in the late ’90s, just before emo’s mainstream wave and hardcore’s metallic turn would redefine the terrain. What’s most important, this EP is not some footnote or unfinished sketch. It is complete in its own right, a short but devastating statement of intent. The songs move with an internal logic. All those patterns emerge, collapse, reconfigure. Tension is built not only through volume but through space, control, and the refusal to give the listener easy resolution. With all the cleverness and unpredictability, The Elusive belonged to a D.C. tradition that valued intelligence without sacrificing power. They wrote like a band that knew their tracks would be listened to closely, dissected, and argued over, and they made sure the material deserved it. And still, this material still sounds fresh. Two and a half decades later, countless bands have borrowed from the post-hardcore palette, some with skill, many without, but few have captured the combination of ferocity and precision that The Elusive achieved in a handful of months. Their music doesn’t pander to nostalgia. It doesn’t need the qualifier of “for fans of.” It stands on its own, bristling with the energy that makes the heart race.
Washington, D.C. has always had a knack for birthing short-lived bands that left behind oversized legacies. The Elusive fit that pattern, carrying forward the restless experimentation of their predecessors while foreshadowing the shape of things to come. If you listen closely, you can already hear the seeds of Q And Not U’s rhythmic daring, the sharpness that would soon define a new wave of Dischord bands. But here it’s rawer, heavier, still tangled in the wires of its own urgency. These six songs may have been written in the span of a year, performed for small crowds, and nearly forgotten in the flood of late ’90s underground releases, but they mattered and shaped musicians who went on to shape others. They captured a sound and a spirit that still reverberates with anyone who believes in the value of music that refuses to be easy. The art can reveal the secret history of our times. That phrase applies here. Sometimes Sounds Collapse is not just the history of this band but an open window into a scene, a moment, and an ethos. It shows what can happen when five people in a basement decide to push themselves past comfort, genre conventions, and the limits of time. It’s proof that even the smallest, most fleeting sparks of punk rock and post-hardcore can illuminate decades. The Elusive did not last, but these six songs did, and hearing them now, pressed to vinyl for the first time, you realize that sometimes the most powerful art comes from intensity, from the sense that sound might collapse, but meaning endures. Head to Expert Work Records for more information about ordering.
Thoughts Words Action 